Last night I rewatched the 2015 interview between the Indian mystic Sadhguru and neuroscientist David Eagleman, held at Congregation Emanu El in Houston, Texas.
For nearly two hours, both men shared their understanding of what it means to be human, and who we are.
After this second viewing, I was left with an abiding sense of marveling confoundedness, a feeling that trying to understand what a human being actually is may be impossible.
I didn’t use to feel this way, however.
For decades, I was convinced I knew where human beings came from and what human life was for. It was all so simple.
I saw myself as a child of God, created in His image and likeness.
This God, the creator of all things, loved me, watched over me, and cared about what I needed and wanted in life.
If God was happy, I was too. If God was sad, I was too.
How could it be otherwise, if I was made to resemble my creator?
I felt proud and confident in who I was and where I was headed.
But underneath all this lay an unexamined assumption: that there was a fixed, concrete “I” for God to love and watch over, or, if I sinned, to punish and judge—pardon the expression, me!
The idea of an I or a me surfaced repeatedly in Sadhguru and Eagleman’s dialogue.
It reminded me of the struggles and conflicts I experienced in the choppy waters of I-ness and me-ness during my earlier years walking a spiritual path.
Whenever I achieved specific goals I’d set for an activity, like collecting street donations or convincing strangers to learn more about my faith community, I felt a sense of accomplishment and God’s approving hand embracing me.
When I failed to achieve the goals I set, I would often doubt myself, feeling something was wrong with me.
Myself. Me. I. All in one sentence!
This self, this sense of me, for good or bad, never left me alone.
In a way, it felt like that pesky barking chihuahua nipping at your heels. When you turn to look behind, it quickly scampers out of sight, only to reappear nipping at the other heel.
The I that felt God’s approval on a good day and the me that felt something was wrong on a bad one seemed less like one fixed self than a shifting one, changing with each situation.
But if this sense of self, this I, or me, keeps shifting, what are we, really?
I can only say how it felt: like a bowl of nervous jelly, shaking and quivering at every poke, desperately trying to press itself into a rock-solid me or I.
Eagleman suggests this self is something the brain builds, with little sign of anything enduring beyond what the brain so intricately constructs.
Sadhguru sees this self as an accumulation, something acquired along the way, beneath which we are simply a piece of life.
When Eagleman pressed him on what this piece of life is, Sadhguru answered with images rather than definitions.
Who or what this I is at any given moment, neither of them could clearly say.
Today, neither can I.
Maybe that is why my confoundedness feels more like marveling than loss.
Near the end of their dialogue, Eagleman says science and mysticism can meet in three words: “I don’t know.”
After decades of being certain about who I was, those three words now feel less like an ending than a beginning.
And, for … oops … me, this “I don’t know” is more fun than “I know.”

